What to Cook with Olive Oil: All the Details from the Best Chef

What Is Olive Oil and Why It Matters

Types of Olive Oil (Extra Virgin, Virgin, Light, Pure)

When someone asks me, “Chef, which olive oil should I be using?” I always reply, “That depends on what you’re cooking.” Here’s a simple breakdown:

Type of Olive Oil	Flavor Profile	Ideal Use	Notes
Extra Virgin Olive Oil	Bold, grassy, peppery	Dressings, finishing oils	Made from the first cold press
Virgin Olive Oil	Milder, slightly fruity	Sauteing, marinades	Slightly higher acidity than EVOO
Pure Olive Oil	Neutral, light	High-heat cooking	Often a blend; refined + virgin oil
Light Olive Oil	Very mild, almost flavorless	Baking, frying	Not lower in calories—“light” means taste

Extra Virgin is what I keep on my counter at all times. It’s the most flavorful and nutritious, but it’s also more sensitive to heat—so for searing or frying, I reach for a pure or light olive oil instead.

---

How Olive Oil Is Made

True olive oil starts with freshly harvested olives—ideally pressed within 24 hours. The process looks like this:

1. Harvesting: Ideally hand-picked, to avoid bruising the fruit.
2. Washing & Grinding: Olives are crushed into a paste.
3. Cold Pressing: This paste is pressed without heat to extract oil—this preserves nutrients and flavor.
4. Separation: Oil is separated from water and solids.
5. Bottling: Dark bottles are used to protect from light.

Many industrial oils use heat or chemicals to extract every last drop—but that sacrifices quality. Cold-pressed extra virgin olive oil is all about purity and taste.

---

Olive Oil Grades

Here’s how the International Olive Council classifies olive oil:

Grade	Acidity Level	Processing Method	Flavor Quality
Extra Virgin	< 0.8%	Cold-pressed, no chemicals	Perfect, no defects
Virgin	< 2%	Cold-pressed	Slight imperfections
Refined	< 0.3%	Chemically processed	Neutral, bland
Pomace	Varies	Extracted from leftovers	Lowest grade

Stick to extra virgin for flavor. If you’re cooking at high temps, a refined blend will work—just don’t expect fireworks on your taste buds.

---

Health Benefits of Olive Oil

Is Olive Oil Good for You?

Absolutely. It’s one of the healthiest fats you can cook with. Extra virgin olive oil is packed with antioxidants, Vitamin E, and monounsaturated fats that support heart health and help reduce inflammation.

As a chef who spends long hours on his feet, I always look for ways to fuel my body smartly—and olive oil has played a big part in that.

---

Olive Oil and Heart Health

Studies from the Mediterranean Diet—something I saw firsthand during a cooking residency in southern Italy—have shown that people who consume olive oil regularly have lower risks of heart disease and stroke. That’s because it:

• Helps reduce LDL (bad) cholesterol
• Increases HDL (good) cholesterol
• Protects blood vessels from inflammation

It’s not just tradition—it’s science-backed.

---

Comparing Olive Oil to Other Cooking Oils

Let’s look at how olive oil stacks up next to other popular fats:

Olive Oil vs. Avocado Oil

Factor	Olive Oil	Avocado Oil
Smoke Point	375–405°F (EVOO)	~520°F
Flavor	Bold, fruity, peppery	Buttery, mild
Best Use	Cold dishes, sautéing	High-heat cooking
Nutrients	Antioxidants, polyphenols	Vitamin E, monounsaturated fats

Verdict: Avocado oil is great for high-heat, but olive oil wins on flavor and antioxidant content.

Olive Oil vs. Butter

Factor	Olive Oil	Butter
Cholesterol	0 mg	31 mg (per tbsp)
Flavor	Grassy, rich	Creamy, savory
Cooking	Doesn’t burn as easily	Burns fast unless clarified

Verdict: I use olive oil for health and butter for indulgence—but often mix both for balance.

Olive Oil vs. Coconut Oil

Factor	Olive Oil	Coconut Oil
Saturated Fat	2g per tbsp	12g per tbsp
Flavor	Subtle, earthy	Strong, coconut-forward
Health	Heart-healthy	Controversial in high doses

Verdict: Coconut oil has its place, but olive oil is safer for daily use.

Cooking with Olive Oil

Can You Cook with Extra Virgin Olive Oil?

Yes, you absolutely can—and I do it daily. There’s a myth floating around that you should never heat extra virgin olive oil. That’s like saying you should never toast good bread. Sure, you can burn it if you’re reckless, but with care, it brings out incredible depth.

Here’s the key: medium heat is your best friend. Use EVOO for sautéing vegetables, starting sauces, or finishing meats in a skillet. Just avoid cranking the burner to high and walking away.

---

Best Olive Oil for Cooking vs. Finishing

Not all olive oils serve the same role. Think of them like wines—some are table wines, others are for sipping.

Use Case	Recommended Olive Oil	Why?
High-heat cooking	Pure or light olive oil	Neutral flavor, higher smoke point
Medium-heat sautéing	Extra virgin olive oil (EVOO)	Rich flavor, good stability
Finishing dishes	High-quality EVOO	Adds aroma and freshness
Baking	Light olive oil	Neutral, doesn’t overpower

In my kitchen, I keep at least two bottles: one robust EVOO for finishing, and a milder one for cooking. It’s like having both sneakers and dress shoes—you need both for different occasions.

---

Smoke Point and Heat Stability

The smoke point of olive oil depends on its purity:

• Extra Virgin Olive Oil: 375–405°F (190–207°C)
• Virgin Olive Oil: ~420°F (215°C)
• Refined/Pure Olive Oil: ~465°F (240°C)
• Light Olive Oil: ~470°F (243°C)

Now, most stovetop sautéing happens around 300–350°F, which means EVOO is just fine—as long as you’re attentive.

Chef tip: If you see the oil shimmer or smell a sharp bitterness, remove it from heat. That’s your sign it’s about to smoke.

---

Tips for Using Olive Oil in Everyday Cooking

Olive Oil in Salads and Marinades

A peppery extra virgin olive oil turns a boring salad into something restaurant-worthy. Here’s my go-to vinaigrette formula:

Ingredient	Ratio
Extra virgin olive oil	3 parts
Acid (lemon juice or vinegar)	1 part
Dijon mustard	1 tsp (optional emulsifier)
Salt + pepper	To taste

I use this for marinating meats too—especially chicken thighs and flank steak. The olive oil carries the flavor deep into the meat.

Roasting and Grilling with Olive Oil

Before anything hits the oven or grill, I toss it in olive oil. Why?

1. Even cooking
2. Enhanced browning
3. Flavor infusion

For vegetables, don’t drown them. A light coating is all you need. Then hit them with salt, garlic powder, and maybe some smoked paprika for a Mediterranean twist.

How to Choose the Best Olive Oil

What to Look for on the Label

When I’m standing in the olive oil aisle with ten different brands staring me down, I look for a few specific details. Trust me—reading the label is everything.

Here’s a checklist I use when shopping:

Label Detail	What It Tells You
“Extra Virgin”	Highest grade; unrefined, with full flavor
Harvest date	Fresher is better—look for oil under 12 months old
Dark glass bottle	Protects oil from light, helps preserve quality
Single origin	More traceable, often higher quality
Cold-pressed	Mechanically extracted without heat, retains nutrients

Chef tip: If a label is vague or lacks harvest and bottling info—skip it. Quality producers are proud of their process and share it up front.

---

Country of Origin: Does It Matter?

Absolutely—but not in the way you might think.

Italy, Spain, Greece, Tunisia—all produce excellent olive oils. But country of origin only tells part of the story. Some mass-market oils blend low-quality oils from multiple countries. What matters more is traceability.

Look for:

• “Estate bottled” or “Single estate” labels
• A PDO or PGI certification (especially in European oils)
• A producer’s name or farm on the bottle

I personally love oils from Sicily, Andalusia, and Crete, but I’ve also used stunning California olive oil from small farms. Don’t chase flags—chase transparency.

---

Organic vs. Non-Organic Olive Oil

Here’s where it gets a little nuanced.

Organic certification means the olives were grown without synthetic pesticides or fertilizers. That’s a plus for sustainability and health, especially if you use a lot of olive oil (and I do).

But—and this is big—non-organic doesn’t always mean low quality. Many small farms follow organic practices but can’t afford the certification. If you’re unsure, research the producer or check their website.

Chef’s take: If you can find a certified organic oil with harvest and bottling info, in a dark glass bottle, and within your budget—grab it.

---

Cold-Pressed, First Press, Stone Milled: What Do They Mean?

Let’s break down the buzzwords:

• Cold-pressed: Mechanically extracted below 80°F (27°C). Keeps flavor and nutrients intact.
• First press: Usually redundant in modern production—EVOO is always first pressed by definition.
• Stone milled: A traditional method using granite wheels to crush olives. More romantic than revolutionary, but sometimes leads to unique flavors.

Here’s a quick visual guide for clarity:

[Infographic: Olive Oil Terminology Cheat Sheet]

| Term           | Meaning                                  | Worth Paying More? |

| Cold-pressed   | Extracted without heat                    |✅ Yes               |

|First press    | Marketing term—standard for EVOO          |❌ Not necessary     |

| Stone milled   | Traditional method, rare but artisanal    |✅ If you love niche oils |

 Final thought from Chef Marcus: The best olive oil is one you’ll use often, love the taste of, and feel good about putting in your food. Trust your palate and find your go-to bottle.

Olive Oil Storage and Shelf Life

Does Olive Oil Go Bad?

Yes, olive oil can go bad—but not in the way milk or meat spoils. It doesn’t grow mold or smell rancid overnight. Instead, it oxidizes and loses its flavor and health benefits over time. Think of it like wine—but in reverse. With age, olive oil gets worse, not better.

In my kitchen, I treat olive oil like a fresh ingredient. If it’s been open for more than 6 months, especially if it wasn’t stored properly, I move on.

How to Store Olive Oil Properly

Here’s what I do in my restaurant—and at home:

Do This	Not This
Store in a dark glass bottle	Use a clear or plastic bottle
Keep it in a cool, dark cupboard	Leave it near the stove or windowsill
Use an airtight pour spout	Let air in after each use

 Chef tip: The ideal temperature is 57°F to 70°F (14°C to 21°C). Think wine cellar—not kitchen counter.

---

Signs of Spoiled Olive Oil

Here’s how I test oil before cooking:

• Smell it: If it smells like crayons, old peanuts, or even glue—it’s gone rancid.
• Taste it: Bitter is good. Sour or waxy is not.
• Look at the color: Dark golden-green is typical. If it’s pale or cloudy without being cold—it may be oxidized.

Chef’s rule: If you wouldn’t dip fresh bread in it, don’t cook with it.

---

Can You Freeze Olive Oil?

Yes, you can—but I rarely recommend it unless you’re storing large quantities for later use. Freezing helps preserve nutrients and flavor, but it also:

• Makes it harder to portion
• Slightly changes the texture
• Takes time to thaw properly

If you do freeze it, use silicone ice cube trays and thaw only what you need.

---

Using Olive Oil in Recipes

Best Recipes Using Olive Oil

Here are four of my go-to recipes that highlight the depth and character of a great EVOO:

Olive Oil Cake

Light, moist, and subtly fruity—perfect with citrus zest or almonds.

Ingredients:

- 1 cup extra virgin olive oil  

- 3 eggs  

- ¾ cup sugar  

- 1 cup almond flour  

- 1 cup all-purpose flour  

- Zest of 1 lemon

Bake at 350°F (175°C) for 40–45 minutes. Serve with berries.

Mediterranean Salad with Olive Oil Dressing

A vibrant, crunchy mix with EVOO shining through the vinaigrette.

Dressing:

- 3 tbsp olive oil  

- 1 tbsp red wine vinegar  

- 1 tsp Dijon mustard  

- Pinch of oregano  

- Salt & pepper to taste

Garlic Olive Oil Pasta

So simple. So satisfying. Ready in 10 minutes.

Ingredients:

- 8 oz spaghetti (al dente)  

- ¼ cup EVOO  

- 4 garlic cloves, thinly sliced  

- Red chili flakes (optional)  

- Fresh parsley

Sauté garlic in oil, toss with pasta and herbs.

Homemade Olive Oil Mayonnaise

Rich, creamy, and completely different from store-bought.

Blend together:

- 1 egg yolk  

- 1 tsp Dijon mustard  

- 1 tbsp lemon juice  

- ¾ cup olive oil (slow drizzle while blending)  

- Salt to taste

---

Olive Oil in Baking: When and How to Use It

EVOO works beautifully in cakes, muffins, and quick breads. I use it whenever I want:

• A moist crumb
• A slightly fruity or herbal note
• An alternative to dairy or butter

 Chef’s tip: Use light-tasting EVOO in recipes where you don’t want an assertive olive flavor. But when paired with citrus, nuts, or herbs—let it sing.

---

Olive Oil Myths and Facts

Is Cooking with Olive Oil Toxic?

No, no, and no again.

The myth comes from the idea that olive oil “burns” at low temperatures. But good-quality extra virgin olive oil has a smoke point of 375–410°F (190–210°C)—plenty high for sautéing, roasting, and even baking.

As long as you don’t overheat it, olive oil is perfectly safe—and packed with antioxidants that protect it during cooking.

---

Does All Olive Oil Taste the Same?

Not even close.

Tasting olive oil is like tasting wine. There are notes of:

• Grass
• Artichoke
• Almond
• Pepper
• Tomato leaf
• Even green banana

Try a flight of three different oils. You’ll see how distinct they are. Some are mild and buttery, others peppery and bold.

Pro move: Pour a little in a wine glass, warm it with your hand, and inhale deeply. Then take a small sip. You’ll never go back to “just any” oil again.

---

Can You Fry with Extra Virgin Olive Oil?

Yes, you can—and I do.

Shallow-frying or pan-frying with EVOO adds flavor that other oils just can’t match. Just don’t let it smoke. Medium heat is your friend.

For deep frying, I’ll often switch to refined olive oil, which has a higher smoke point and neutral flavor. But EVOO for eggs, fish, and vegetables? Absolutely.

15+ Frequently Asked Questions about Olive Oil