13. Engaging with Local Communities - Fran Igoe

  • Published on
    10-Apr-2017

  • View
    297

  • Download
    0

Transcript

  • Engaging with Local Communities, experience to date!

    Presentation to Catchment Management Network Meeting 24th February 2017 Fran Igoe, Southern Regional Coordinator, Local Authorities Waters and Communities Office

  • Presentation Overview

    Developing LAWCOs approach to public engagement

    River Suir PE Pilot Learnings to date Examples of community participation

    to date

  • What is the role of the Local Authority Waters and Communities Office?

    1. Coordination & Support LAs

    2. Mobilise Community Participation Participation, not consultation Development of RBMPs Implementation Actions Local water enhancement activities

    3. Support to Minister & EPA

  • Approach

    Awareness raising Public engagement Public participation (enabling) Partnership networking Targeting priority areas where possible But also :- protect existing status

  • Community Participation National organisations

    Local Community Development Committees (LCDCs)

    Public Participation Network (PPN) NGOs

    Leader Companies

    Irish Local Development Network (ILDN)

    Fisheries Local Action Groups (FLAGS)

    Group Water Schemes

    Rivers Trusts, Friends of etc, etc, etc .

  • Community Participation Local organisations/communities

    Local Communities Groups

    Farming interest (Macra, Teagasc, IFA,ICMSA etc) inc Locally Led

    Fishing (TAFI, NARA, FISTA, local clubs)

    Heritage + Tourism interests

    Coastal communities

    Gaeltacht areas TidyTowns

    Environmental NGOs e.g., SWAN, Coastwatch, An Taisce, etc. , Birdwatch, Irish Whale and

    Dolphin Group etc

    Wildlife groups (IWF, Nature Networks etc)

    Recreational Groups (Walkers, Kayakers, Canoeing clubs, sailing and boating etc)

  • Building on existing initiatives

    Looking for collaborations and joined up approaches An Taisce Clean coasts, Blue Flag, Green schools Coastwatch networks and monitoring Farm events, Heritage days Leave no Trace LA Environmental Awareness Officers Community and enterprise Universities and schools events

  • Developing Local Partnerships through doing?

    Networks representing communities LEADER/FLAGS/other funding opportunities Other potential funding synergies (e.g., SICAP)

    initiatives Community awareness raising etc Potential to develop larger projects and

    national strategies (e.g., Ecogym)

  • Water/biodiversityProject examples

    General Amenity Beach clean River/ coastal walk Amenity area/ picnic area Bird watching Canoe/kayaking

    Public awareness Leaflet of local information Pride of place/Tidy towns project Schools Citizen science Targeted surveys

    Restoration/conservation Planting of trees River restoration works Fish passage Invasive species control Silt trapping

    Could tie in with Programme of measures under the Water Framework Directive

  • List of projects/potential projects

    Co. Mayo: R. Moy association formed and launched on Wednesday in Mount Flacon Hotel in Ballina going to develop plan for R. Moy Bangor Erris community group looking at project on Owenmore River Community group inquiring about project on Lough Cara GMIT also engaged Co. Kildare R. Ryewater Kildare meth border, community group (with assistance from Kildare LA) doing sampling on river and looking at how they can improve river. Co. Dublin: R. Mayne North Dublin, community activist trying to establish group with a view to establishing a walk along river from airport to coast. Santry / Naniken Rivers Dublin City Co proposing project with assistance of LAWCO, project will be community led Co. Donegal: Cloughaneely Angling Association, North Donegal: sought funding for control of Invasive species along River Corridors Inishown Rivers Trust education and outreach Co. Monaghan: River Blackwater Catchment Trust: control of Invasive species along River Blackwater River riparian vegetation management (fencing and address negative impacts of Tunnelling), River Restoration (habitat restoration and bank stabilisation) on the Mountain Water River. Emy & District Anglers interested in automated flow monitoring and potentially flow control at the heavily modified Emy Lough & a weir rehabilitation, re-establish ecological sustainable flows in the river. Co. Leitrim - Erne Rivers Trusts - a scientific review of the River Erne and how the Salmon numbers could be restored Coast: Coastwatch public meetings animation/training for draft RBD adopt a coastal stream and managed sustainably into the future.

  • List of projects/potential projects

    Co. Mayo: R. Moy association formed and launched on Wednesday in Mount Flacon Hotel in Ballina going to develop plan for R. Moy Bangor Erris community group looking at project on Owenmore River Community group inquiring about project on Lough Cara GMIT also engaged Co. Kildare R. Ryewater Kildare meth border, community group (with assistance from Kildare LA) doing sampling on river and looking at how they can improve river. Co. Dublin: R. Mayne North Dublin, community activist trying to establish group with a view to establishing a walk along river from airport to coast. Santry / Naniken Rivers Dublin City Co proposing project with assistance of LAWCO, project will be community led Co. Donegal: Cloughaneely Angling Association, North Donegal: sought funding for control of Invasive species along River Corridors Inishown Rivers Trust education and outreach Co. Monaghan: River Blackwater Catchment Trust: control of Invasive species along River Blackwater River riparian vegetation management (fencing and address negative impacts of Tunnelling), River Restoration (habitat restoration and bank stabilisation) on the Mountain Water River. Emy & District Anglers interested in automated flow monitoring and potentially flow control at the heavily modified Emy Lough & a weir rehabilitation, re-establish ecological sustainable flows in the river. Co. Leitrim - Erne Rivers Trusts - a scientific review of the River Erne and how the Salmon numbers could be restored Coast: Coastwatch public meetings animation/training for draft RBD adopt a coastal stream and managed sustainably into the future.

  • River Suir: Pilot project

    Public engagement R Suir catchment 16 Public meetings 4 Counties (4 LAs) Initially 6 meetings/Tipp (OPW

    CFRAMs PCDs) Awareness, WFD, LAWCO, -community work -Feedback for RBD -Catchment partnership?

  • What does the Waterford Estuary and your local rivers mean to you in Dunmore East?

    Haven Hotel, Dunmore East, December 12th 2016

  • River Suir - European importance

    Crayfish Salmon

    Freshwater Pearl Mussel Otter

    http://duhallowlife.com/node/41http://duhallowlife.com/node/42http://duhallowlife.com/node/46

  • Small coastal streams are

    important habitat for young sea trout

    (IFI)

  • New forestry approach for farmers with land along river banks (potential buffer

    zones- recreational areas)

    Promotion of practical participation initiatives - how communities and landowners can get involved

  • Clonmel Carrick-on-Suir

    River Nire Waterford

    Piltown

    KIlsheelin

    R. Nire contributes 28% of Suir trout stock Source: Massa-Gallucci and Mariani (2011) A genetic study of the mixed trout populations of the Boyne and Suir River catchments.

    Ballymacarbry

  • Golden

    The River Suir Catchment

    Thurles

    Cahir

    Tipperary town

    Piltown Carrick-on-Suir

    Ardfinnan

    Templemore

    Holycross

    Newcastle

    Clonmel

    Knocklofty Waterford

    Ballymacarbury Ballyhack/Arthu Portlaw

    Duncannon Dunmore East

    Freshwater

    Transitional

    Coasta

  • Joib

    LA Environment staff also in attendance to lend backup

    Joint presentation given with Wexford CoCo (Mairead Shore/Brendan Cooney) on priority waterbody (Duncannon)

    Input from Coastwatch also 18 local Newspaper articles 6 Radio interviews

  • Walking 2%

    [CATEGORY NAME]

    [PERCENTAGE]

    Angl ing 9%

    Fisheries 4%

    Heri tage 2%

    Engineering 1%

    Tidy towns 4%

    Farming 4%

    [CATEGORY NAME]

  • Towards connecting communities in the Suir Catchment

  • 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    Losing link with river

    Lack of surveillance and prosecution

    Erosion of river banks

    Water Quality Issues

    Pollution & flytipping

    Navigation

    Decrease in fish stock and biodiversity

    Flooding

    No swimming/lifeguards

    Education & awareness raising

    Invasive Species

    Sewage

    River Access

    Silt, gravel and vegetation

    Tunnelling and trees in river

    Governance of Rivers - too many Agencies

    Lack of joined up thinking

    Most commonly cited issues raised at River Suir Public Meetings 2016 (n=16)

    No of meetings issue raised

  • 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10

    Losing link with river

    Lack of surveillance and prosecution

    Erosion of river banks

    Water Quality Issues

    Pollution & flytipping

    Navigation

    Decrease in fish stock and biodiversity

    Flooding

    No swimming/lifeguards

    Education & awareness raising

    Invasive Species

    Sewage

    River Access

    Silt, gravel and vegetation

    Tunnelling and trees in river

    Governance of Rivers - too many Agencies

    Lack of joined up thinking

    Most commonly cited issues raised at River Suir Public Meetings 2016 (n=16)

    No of meetings issue raised

  • LAWCO

    Ardfinnan Paddlers Waterford CoCo Heritage Officer

    Tipp CoCo Carrick Adminstrator

    Tipp CoCo Environment

    Clonmel Canoe Club

    Clonmel Canoe Club Blueway Dev Officer

    Tipp CoCo Sports Partnership

    NPWS

    Tipp CoCo

    Inland Fisheries

    Outside of Picture Tipp CoCo Heritage Officer LAWCO

    Community participation in biosecurity planning

  • IFI Fisheries Environmental Officer

    Laune Angler Laune Angler

    LAWCO LAWCO LAWCO

    Kerry CoCo Planning

    Kerry CoCO Biodiversity Officer

    IFI Assistant inspector

    IFI Regional Director

    Working to bridge planning requirements and community aspirations River Laune: - potential hydromorphogical pressure vs environmental benefit a potential model?

  • Source: EPA / Teagasc 2006 indicative soil type map Slide courtesy Katie Tedd

    River Blackwater catchment

    River Allow

    River Funshion

    River Blackwater

    Other Catchment Meetings shoots of networks forming? River Allow meeting (7/12/16)

    River Lee catchment

    Reps from three catchment were present

  • Communities already providing information on:

    Invasive species

    Pollution issues

    Land management issues

    Biodiversity information

    Detailed trout genetic information that may be useful for prioritisation of High Status sites

  • Community activity Practical example 1

    Hydromorphological pressure (drainage)

  • OPW R. Suir Consultations

    River Suir Pilot for OPW Consultations complete- flood management

    options proposed We notified attendees on deadline (Dec 13th),

    sent them the draft CFRAMS and how to comment

    Some proposed options include dredging of river = hydromorphological pressure

    Not only did we increase their consultations on the PCDs but also online submissions

  • Community submission Fethard Tourism and Business Group Clashawley and Killusty Anglers Fethard Heritage Fethard Commuity Group

    OPW preferred option = embankment, wall and >1km dredging Clashawley = important Salmon and trout river Above submission identified other options which may reduce/eliminate the need for dredging: 1. Modification on existing road bridge and 2. Replacement of foot bridge

    Potential: avoid hydromorphological pressure/deterioration

  • River restoration/community amenity

    Community activity Practical example 2

    The Well of Ara Project

  • The bigger picture?

    1. Reconnect community with river 2. Tie in with Town and Village Renewal scheme 3. Help underpin efforts to address industrial and urban

    pollution issues 4. Help support upstream buyin to planned Agri-investigations

    Location of proposed walk

    Coop

    Predominantly farmland

  • https://www.google.ie/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiG-_rX8qnNAhVKL8AKHcgoAPMQjRwIBw&url=https://twitter.com/ercipproject&psig=AFQjCNHhZFzGWNQWH93muauZCr0KPwUNwQ&ust=1466075396095387

  • Public meeting in Tipperary Town 3 Radio interviews one specific to project Presentation to School Board of Management Update Board in principal in agreement of

    proposal referring now to board of trustees.

    https://www.google.ie/url?sa=i&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=images&cd=&cad=rja&uact=8&ved=0ahUKEwiG-_rX8qnNAhVKL8AKHcgoAPMQjRwIBw&url=https://twitter.com/ercipproject&psig=AFQjCNHhZFzGWNQWH93muauZCr0KPwUNwQ&ust=1466075396095387

  • Invasive species removal

    Community activity Practical example 3

  • Kilkeran Lough/lagoon: Castlefreke

    Small coastal catchment

    Atypical in a number of aspects

    Key stakeholders Farmers Environmentalists Anglers? Rowers Surfers Wider community

  • Conservation importance: NATURA 2000 Features of Interest Coastal lagoons

    [1150] Embryonic

    shifting dunes [2110]

    Shifting dunes along the shoreline with Ammophila arenaria (white dunes) [2120]

    Fixed coastal dunes with herbaceous vegetation (grey dunes) [2130

  • River

  • Kilkeran Lough:

    Castlefeakle H balsam risk

    high Small area Vulnerable

    catchment to colonisation

    Visit on 4th Aug 16

    Removed in 24th Sept 16

  • Around the country

    Rivers Trusts seem to be gaining some traction.

    Other catchment arrangements also evolving.

    Interest from Agri-food sector Environmental Stewardship Local Authority initiatives:

    Meath CoCo setting up a catchment management group for the beach at Laytown-Bettystown.

    Wicklow CoCo developing a ICM pilot catchment project. Dublin City are establishing a WFD office.

    Wexford CoCo established farmer friendly catchment approach to catchment draining onto Duncannon Beech

  • Communication Strategy Traditional Media

    Social media EPA media (App) Catchment.ie

  • Conclusion

    Public interested Water based activities Heritage Economy/tourism Peoples concerns are local

    River Basin Management Plan People feel there is a lack of joined up thinking in water management

    in Ireland Making the WFD relevant Public participation key Careful thought into how public can be engaged

  • IF you are going to be thinking anything, you might as well think big!

  • THANK YOU

  • THANK YOU

  • Peoples concerns are local, not national, not regional, we have to assist in delivering the local action and also translating these into programmes, priorities and policy where required.

    Slide Number 1Presentation OverviewSlide Number 3Slide Number 4Slide Number 5What is the role of the Local Authority Waters and Communities Office?ApproachCommunity ParticipationNational organisationsCommunity ParticipationLocal organisations/communitiesBuilding on existing initiativesDeveloping Local Partnerships through doing?Water/biodiversityProject examplesSlide Number 13Slide Number 14River Suir: Pilot projectWhat does the Waterford Estuary and your local rivers mean to you in Dunmore East?Slide Number 17River Suir - European importanceSmall coastal streams are important habitat for young sea trout (IFI)New forestry approach for farmers with land along river banks (potential buffer zones- recreational areas)Slide Number 21Slide Number 22Slide Number 23Slide Number 24Slide Number 25Slide Number 26Slide Number 27Slide Number 28Slide Number 29Slide Number 30AnglingTowards connecting communities in the Suir CatchmentSlide Number 33Slide Number 34Community participation in biosecurity planningSlide Number 36River Allow catchmentCommunities already providing information on:Community activityPractical example 1OPW R. Suir ConsultationsSlide Number 41The Well of Ara ProjectThe bigger picture?Slide Number 44Slide Number 45Slide Number 46Kilkeran Lough/lagoon:CastlefrekeConservation importance: NATURA 2000Slide Number 49Slide Number 50Slide Number 51Kilkeran Lough:CastlefeakleAround the countrySlide Number 54Slide Number 55Conclusion Slide Number 57Slide Number 58Slide Number 59Slide Number 60